Why did Charan Singh break away from Congress when he was already one of its prominent leaders and had served as a minister in the state government? His departure was not a sudden decision. The conflict involved his ambition to become chief minister, factional rivalries within Congress, disagreements over allegations of corruption and failed negotiations with Indira Gandhi.
To challenge Congress, Charan Singh accepted the difficult task of bringing together parties with fundamentally different ideologies, including the Bharatiya Jana Sangh, associated with Hindutva and cultural concerns, and the Communist Party of India (CPI), which represented left-wing politics. His role in this experiment helped establish his reputation as an architect of coalition governments in India.
The episode became a landmark not only for Uttar Pradesh but also for national politics, demonstrating how ideological divisions could be set aside to create new political alliances. Charan Singh’s rebellion also became a symbol of farmers’ political aspirations and the emergence of powerful regional leaders in Indian politics.
The Battle Began with the Chief Minister’s Post
The results of the 1967 Uttar Pradesh Assembly election reflected a major political shift. Congress won 199 of the 425 seats contested, falling short of the majority mark of 213. The Bharatiya Jana Sangh made significant gains with 98 seats, while the Samyukta Socialist Party secured 44. The Communist Party of India won 13 seats, and the Swatantra Party secured 12.
Congress remained the largest party, but its longstanding political dominance was weakening.
Following the election, a struggle for the chief minister’s position erupted within Congress. Chandra Bhanu Gupta and Chaudhary Charan Singh were already political rivals, and Charan Singh also aspired to lead the state government. He wanted to stake his claim to the leadership of the Congress legislature party.
However, the party leadership feared that an open contest over leadership would further weaken Congress, which had already lost ground in the election. The high command did not give Charan Singh’s claim the importance he sought.
According to charansingh.org, a website documenting Charan Singh’s political life, three representatives of Indira Gandhi held discussions with him and persuaded him to withdraw his claim in favour of Chandra Bhanu Gupta.
Charan Singh agreed, but placed a condition: certain ministers in Gupta’s proposed cabinet, whose reputations had come under scrutiny because of corruption allegations, should be removed. Charan Singh maintained that although an agreement had been reached on this understanding, his condition was not fulfilled.
His dissatisfaction deepened, bringing the dispute to a decisive point. For Charan Singh, the issue was no longer merely whether he would become chief minister. He presented it as a question of how Congress operated internally and whether its leadership honoured its commitments. At the same time, his own political ambition remained an important part of the episode.
Charan Singh also had ideological differences with the Congress leadership. He prioritised agriculture, farmers and the rural economy, and his economic thinking differed from Jawaharlal Nehru’s capital-intensive industrialisation model. His commitment to rural economic development was reflected in his lifelong preference for handwoven khadi clothing.
He strongly supported farmers’ interests, individual landholdings and rural development. He disagreed with Nehru-era policies favouring cooperative farming and was unhappy with the growing influence of urban interests within the party. Factionalism and the struggle for power within Congress further intensified his dissatisfaction.
April 1, 1967: Charan Singh Breaks Away from Congress
Chandra Bhanu Gupta eventually formed a minority government on March 14–15, 1967, with the support of independent legislators. Charan Singh, however, refused to join his cabinet.
The decisive confrontation came during a vote on the motion of thanks to the Governor’s address in the state Assembly.
On April 1, 1967, Charan Singh and 16–17 fellow Congress legislators voted with the opposition against the motion. The proposal was passed by 215 votes to 198, a defeat equivalent to a loss of confidence in the government. Gupta’s government fell after barely 17–18 days in office.
Born in 1902, Charan Singh had joined Congress in 1927. Nearly 40 years later, on April 1, 1967, he broke away from the party.
The development was a major setback for Congress, one of the dominant political forces in contemporary Indian history.
According to the research of political historian Paul Brass, opposition parties viewed the episode as evidence that Congress’s hold on power was weakening.
Charan Singh’s departure proved decisive. Congress lacked a majority in the Uttar Pradesh Assembly, and a section of its own legislators had now defected. The opposition saw an opportunity to form a government, with Charan Singh emerging as its leader. However, he faced the challenge of securing the support of 213 legislators required for a majority.
How Did the Jana Sangh and Communists Come Together?
The answer lay in the political strategy taking shape at the time. Ahead of the 1967 elections, opposition parties were already exploring ways to challenge Congress through broader cooperation.
Socialist leader Ram Manohar Lohia advocated collaboration among non-Congress parties to remove Congress from power. This approach became widely known as non-Congressism.
Under this strategy, political parties accepted that they did not necessarily have to abandon their core ideologies to defeat Congress. They could form a common government despite substantial differences in their social bases and economic policies.
The Bharatiya Jana Sangh had 98 MLAs, the Samyukta Socialist Party had 44, and the Communist Party of India had 13. The Swatantra Party, Praja Socialist Party, Republican Party, Communist Party of India (Marxist) and independent legislators also played important roles.
Charan Singh brought another 17 legislators from Congress, helping the opposition consolidate its numbers.
The political arithmetic included 98 legislators from the Jana Sangh, 44 from the Samyukta Socialist Party, 13 from the Communist Party of India, 12 from the Swatantra Party, 11 from the Praja Socialist Party, and 40 from other groups and independents.
The alliance came to be known as the Samyukta Vidhayak Dal (SVD), or United Legislators’ Party.
Nanaji Deshmukh from the Jana Sangh and leaders from the socialist camp played important roles in building opposition unity. Socialist leaders Ram Manohar Lohia and Raj Narain were focused on removing Congress from power. For the Jana Sangh, the alliance offered a significant opportunity to challenge the ruling party.
The coming together of these groups did not represent ideological agreement. Instead, they shared the immediate objective of replacing Congress. Left-wing parties and the Jana Sangh retained their distinct political identities while choosing to form a government under the SVD banner.
A common minimum programme was agreed upon to run the government, while cabinet representation was determined in proportion to the legislative strength of the participating parties.
Charan Singh Forms Jan Congress in the Name of the People
Explaining his decision to leave Congress, Charan Singh said he had acted in response to the “Call of the people.”
He named his new party Jan Congress. It later became the Bharatiya Kranti Dal (BKD).
Charan Singh Becomes UP’s First Non-Congress Chief Minister Within 48 Hours
Following Charan Singh’s break with Congress, the opposition parties under the United Legislators’ Party elected him as their leader. The alliance was not the platform of a single political party but a collective arrangement involving several opposition groups represented in the Assembly and legislators who had left Congress.
With the alliance’s support, Charan Singh staked his claim to form the government. Governor Vishwanath Das gave him the opportunity to do so.
After the Congress government fell on April 1, Uttar Pradesh was on the verge of a historic political change.
On April 3, 1967, just 48 hours later, Charan Singh took the oath of office as chief minister of Uttar Pradesh, becoming the state’s first non-Congress chief minister.
Ram Prakash Gupta of the Jana Sangh became deputy chief minister. The coalition included Charan Singh’s Jan Congress, the Jana Sangh, the Samyukta Socialist Party, the Communist Party of India, the Swatantra Party, the Praja Socialist Party and other groups.
How Long Did the Coalition Government Survive?
The coalition’s greatest strength also became its biggest weakness. Although the participating parties had united to remove Congress from power, they disagreed on government policies. Their shared objective of defeating Congress was the principal factor holding them together.
Once in power, disagreements emerged over cabinet positions, policymaking and political influence. Language, land and corruption became important issues of contention.
Land revenue was a major source of conflict. According to charansingh.org, left-wing parties favoured abolishing land revenue, but Charan Singh opposed the proposal, arguing that the state lacked sufficient resources.
The coalition also failed to reach a consensus on a strike by state employees. Charan Singh adopted a tough approach to suppress the strike, while other parties in the alliance had promised to support the employees’ demands.
Within a month of the government’s formation, legislators and leaders began moving from one party to another, further weakening the coalition.
The language controversy became another major point of conflict.
In January 1968, the Samyukta Socialist Party launched an “English हटाओ” (Remove English) movement. Two of its ministers courted arrest as part of the agitation. Charan Singh ordered police action, angering the socialist party, which withdrew from the coalition around January 5.
Other parties also began withdrawing their support, leaving the government in a minority.
On February 17, 1968, Charan Singh submitted his resignation to the Governor and recommended the dissolution of the Assembly. President’s Rule was imposed on February 25.
According to a report by the Hindustan Times, after resigning as chief minister, Charan Singh said, “There is no doubt that it was a new experiment, but it was not a happy experiment.”
Responding to questions about whether he had compromised on principles for the sake of power, he said, “While resigning from my post, I do not blame anyone…”
The 1967 political experiment in Uttar Pradesh exposed both the possibilities and the limitations of opposition unity. Charan Singh’s government demonstrated that parties with sharply contrasting ideologies could combine their legislative strength to dislodge Congress, but the subsequent collapse also revealed how difficult it was to sustain such an alliance without agreement on key policies. The episode remains a defining moment in the evolution of coalition politics in India.
About The Author
Comment List