Bangladesh Seeks Answers After Saudi Arabia Executes Two Nationals in Secret

Bangladesh Seeks Answers After Saudi Arabia Executes Two Nationals in Secret

Bangladesh is seeking answers after Saudi Arabia executed Nazrul Islam and Sweety Akhtar on 14 October. Conflicting arrest allegations, an undisclosed verdict and questions over consular assistance have intensified scrutiny of the cases.

Anger is mounting in Bangladesh after Saudi Arabia executed two Bangladeshi nationals for allegedly committing an “indecent act” inside a mosque in Mecca, with questions intensifying over the circumstances of the case, the lack of transparency surrounding the proceedings and Dhaka’s apparent failure to receive prior notification of their executions.

Bangladesh has sought an explanation from Riyadh, but its public response has remained relatively muted. Human rights organisations and citizens, however, have expressed outrage, particularly over reports that Bangladesh was kept uninformed until after the two nationals had been put to death.

The two Bangladeshis, identified in media reports as Nazrul Islam and Sweety, also spelt Siti or Suety, Akhtar, were executed on 14 October. They were sentenced to death under ta’zir, a form of punishment under Islamic law that leaves the penalty to the judge’s discretion.

Saudi Arabia’s Interior Ministry did not disclose the specific act the two were accused of committing, identify the mosque where the alleged incident took place or provide details of when they were arrested. The ministry stated only that they had violated the “sanctity” of the mosque.

Read More Argentina University Protests Intensify as Milei’s Austerity Cuts Threaten Free Education

According to The Daily Star, Nazrul Islam and Sweety Akhtar were included in a list of prisoners shared by Saudi Arabia with Bangladesh. However, the list did not mention their death sentences. Their families reportedly learnt about the executions through media reports rather than official communication.

Read More Russia-Iran Military Cooperation Strains US Weapons Stocks and Global Security

Dhaka has so far appeared keen to limit the diplomatic fallout. On Monday, Bangladesh State Minister for Foreign Affairs Humaiun Kobir described the executions as “very disappointing” and said the government had sought an explanation from Saudi Arabia, which Bangladesh considers a “friendly” partner. Kobir also expressed hope that bilateral relations would grow stronger.

Read More Trump Halts Russia Sanctions Ahead of Deadline, Raising Questions Over India and Ukraine

During discussions with Saudi Ambassador Abdullah Zafer bin Abiyah, the importance of being “mindful” of the host country’s laws was also raised. State Minister Shama Obaed Islam reportedly said, “The execution of two Bangladeshis in Saudi Arabia serves as a major lesson for us.”

She added that Bangladesh was still awaiting a copy of the verdict to establish the details of the case.

The government’s restrained response contrasts with the anger expressed by sections of Bangladeshi society over both the executions and the manner in which the cases were handled.

“Anger is growing in Bangladesh over Saudi Arabia’s execution of two Bangladeshi nationals without prior information being provided to Bangladesh,” posted @Jefta_222 on X.

Bangladeshi Supreme Court advocate and human rights defender Barrister Khan Khalid Adnan has also called for the disclosure of details surrounding the cases, citing the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations.

“Article 36 of the convention requires authorities to inform detained foreigners of their consular rights without delay. If a detainee requests it, the relevant consulate must also be notified without delay,” he said.

JusticeMakers Bangladesh in France (JMBF), a Paris-based human rights organisation, has also condemned the executions.

“JMBF firmly rejects capital punishment for alleged violations of religious, moral, or social norms. JMBF is particularly alarmed by information indicating that the two Bangladeshi nationals were denied legal representation and consular assistance during the proceedings leading to their executions,” the organisation said.

JMBF added that the executions were “fundamentally incompatible with human dignity and internationally recognised principles of justice.”

A confidential Bangladeshi consular memo has added another layer of uncertainty to the circumstances surrounding the executions. Dhaka Tribune reported on Tuesday that the two Bangladeshis had been arrested approximately three years ago, with the records revealing allegations that differ from the explanation subsequently provided by Saudi Arabia.

According to the memo, Nazrul Islam was detained on 1 August 2023 under Saudi Arabia’s cybercrime law, while Sweety Akhtar was arrested the following day on allegations of adultery. The memo does not explain the discrepancy between these allegations and the Saudi authorities’ statement that the two were executed for an “indecent act” inside a mosque.

The families of both executed Bangladeshis are now demanding answers about the charges, legal proceedings and circumstances that led to their deaths.

Fazal Mia, Sweety Akhtar’s father, said he had not been informed of the death sentence and was still awaiting official confirmation that his daughter had been executed.

“We do not know what has happened to my daughter. We do not even know whether she is alive or dead. We have only heard rumours,” he said.

Nazrul Islam, 22, had left Bangladesh in 2022 and worked as a cleaner in Saudi Arabia, his family told The Daily Star in a report titled “Our son was killed without a fair trial”.

Although his family knew he was in prison, they received no advance notice of his execution and learnt of his death through media reports. They have been unable to verify crucial details, including the charges against him, whether he received legal assistance and whether he was given an opportunity to defend himself in court.

“If my son was executed without just cause, I want justice,” Islam’s father, Abdul Basir, told The Daily Star.

Abdul Basir also told Jago News 24, as cited in a report by ThePrint, that his family did not know Akhtar.

The executions have raised questions about the transparency of the proceedings, the availability of legal representation and consular assistance, and the communication between Saudi authorities and Bangladesh. Dhaka’s request for an explanation and its wait for the verdict remain central to efforts to establish what happened to Nazrul Islam and Sweety Akhtar, while their families continue to seek official answers about the cases.

 

Tags:

About The Author

Post Comment

Comment List

Latest News

Ladakh’s First Government Medical College Set to Open in 2027-28 After Key Rule Exemption Ladakh’s First Government Medical College Set to Open in 2027-28 After Key Rule Exemption
Ladakh’s first government medical college in Leh is expected to begin classes in 2027-28 after the Centre grants a key...
Gujarat Clean-Up Drive Clears Space Equal to 18 Hospitals, Removes 6 Lakh Items
PM Internship Scheme: 30,000 Youth Beneficiaries Against 30 Lakh Target in Two Years

Live Cricket Score

Advertisement

Science & Tech

Samsung Galaxy S27 Leak Reveals Front Design of Three Flagship Phones Samsung Galaxy S27 Leak Reveals Front Design of Three Flagship Phones
Samsung Galaxy S27 leaks reveal alleged screen protectors for the S27, S27 Plus and S27 Ultra, hinting at display sizes...
Samsung Galaxy F70 5G Price Confusion: Why Rs 17,999 and Rs 19,999 Both Appear

Health

Living With Diabetes: How Blood Sugar Fluctuations Can Affect Mental Health Living With Diabetes: How Blood Sugar Fluctuations Can Affect Mental Health
Living with diabetes can take an emotional toll beyond blood sugar management. Discover how glucose fluctuations, anxiety and sleep problems...
Four Vaccines May Help Protect Heart Health, Research Suggests

Lifestyle

 Food Pharmer Sparks Nationwide Debate Over Cheeslings Ingredients, Raises Questions on Food Safety Standards Food Pharmer Sparks Nationwide Debate Over Cheeslings Ingredients, Raises Questions on Food Safety Standards
Food influencer Revant Himatsingka, known as Food Pharmer, has sparked nationwide debate after revealing Cheeslings’ low cheese content and high...
From Gym Floor to City Streets: The Unexpected Revival of the Lopifit Treadmill-Bike
crossorigin="anonymous">