India-Pakistan Smog Crisis: Can Toxic Air Bring the Two Nations Together?
India-Pakistan smog crisis continues to worsen as pollution engulfs Delhi and Lahore. Could shared environmental challenges, cross-border cooperation and smog diplomacy finally bring the two nations to the negotiating table?
As winter approaches, air pollution levels begin to rise, pushing several cities in both countries towards hazardous levels. During winter, the subcontinent witnesses two kinds of smog. One covers cities such as Delhi and Lahore, while the other takes the form of mutual accusations that follow.
Some experts and observers have suggested 'smog diplomacy' or 'climate diplomacy' as a possible way to bring New Delhi and Islamabad to the negotiating table. They believe discussions on air pollution and climate-related issues could help both countries find solutions to the toxic air affecting their populations. Despite sharing one of the world's most polluted regions, India and Pakistan have not managed to initiate meaningful dialogue on the issue. Air pollution remains a potential area of cooperation where political differences could have a relatively limited impact and citizens of both countries could benefit in the long run.
The two Punjab regions, one in India and the other in Pakistan, face a similar problem. The day after Diwali, Pakistan's Punjab Environment Minister blamed air arriving from India for the pollution in Lahore. Such accusations have become an annual occurrence. In 2024, Pakistan Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz also expressed her willingness to discuss the smog crisis with her counterpart in India. She said she wanted to visit India and invite Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann to Pakistan.
Maryam Nawaz had said, "This issue will have to be resolved diplomatically with India. I am thinking of writing a letter to the Chief Minister of Indian Punjab. This is not a political issue but a matter of humanity."
Stubble burning is one of the major reasons behind the rise in winter pollution in both Punjab regions. At the beginning of the season, farmers burn leftover crop residue to clear their fields for the next crop. Although burning agricultural residue is not entirely legal in either country and is subject to restrictions and fines, it remains the quickest and cheapest method for farmers to clear their fields.
Apart from stubble burning, vehicle emissions, industrial pollution and toxic gases released by construction activities also contribute to deteriorating air quality. During winter, specific weather conditions prevent polluted air from dispersing, causing it to remain concentrated in the same areas.
Pakistan has repeatedly blamed India for the problem. However, a study by the RAND Corporation states that neither country is entirely responsible for cross-border pollution. During the early winter or post-monsoon stubble-burning season, when pollution levels are at their highest, most of the smoke originates from crop-residue burning in India's Punjab region rather than Pakistan. However, much of this smoke moves towards the Indo-Gangetic plains between India and Pakistan instead of travelling towards Pakistan, affecting Indian cities.
If stubble-burning incidents increase in Pakistan during this season, they could influence the spread of pollution across the border. During the pre-monsoon stubble-burning season, pollution levels are generally lower, while the extent of stubble burning in both countries remains almost similar. This indicates that pollution caused by crop-residue burning in both countries affects air quality within their own territories as well as across the border.
Pakistan's leading newspaper Dawn began investigating these claims as early as 2019. It analysed fire incidents in different regions and unusual temperature variations to examine the alleged connection between Indian stubble burning and Lahore's smog. The investigation concluded that the claim that stubble burning in India was responsible for smog in Lahore was statistically incorrect. The data indicating a connection between the two was also described as "very weak".
The newspaper further observed that such allegations increase tensions between the two countries and make it more difficult to create an environment for cross-border cooperation between the two Punjab regions to tackle air pollution.
There is also evidence that winter smog in Pakistan is primarily generated within the country. According to the Pakistan Air Quality Initiative (PAQI), satellite data recorded 18,825 fire incidents in Pakistan's Punjab region between October 1 and November 9. Of these, approximately 16,714 incidents were identified as probable crop-residue burning events.
The central question, therefore, is whether one country is responsible for the pollution affecting the other, as Pakistan's allegations suggest. Available evidence points towards several contributing factors. However, the reasons behind stubble burning and its consequences remain largely similar across the Punjab regions of both countries. Despite facing a common challenge, neither side has so far demonstrated any joint initiative to address the problem.
The consequences of air pollution for human health and life are already well established. According to a Lancet report, approximately 1,718,000 people died in India in 2022 due to human-caused air pollution. Meanwhile, a report by the Pakistan Air Quality Initiative (PAQI) states that more than 128,000 people die prematurely every year in Pakistan because of air pollution.
Prolonged exposure to polluted air is reducing the average life expectancy of people in Pakistan by approximately 3.9 years. In Lahore, the reduction is as high as seven years. This is particularly significant because the constitutions of both countries recognise the right to clean air and a healthy environment. In India, this right is covered under Article 21 of the Constitution, while in Pakistan, it is protected under Article 9A.
With dialogue between India and Pakistan currently suspended, initiating discussions on smog could offer a relatively straightforward opportunity to reduce tensions. Such cooperation may not carry a significant political cost, but it would require willingness from both governments. This remains a challenge because several individuals and political leaders in both countries oppose any form of dialogue.
The two countries could also pursue cooperation through regional agreements or with assistance from the World Bank. One possible framework is the Male Declaration, signed in 1998 by eight South Asian countries. The initiative could be revived to support regional efforts against air pollution.
An agreement between India and Pakistan specifically focused on air quality could also be a constructive step. However, discussions could begin by involving countries across the wider region. This approach may help New Delhi and Islamabad avoid the discomfort and risks associated with direct bilateral engagement. Such regional cooperation is particularly important because several South Asian countries share interconnected air systems.
An 'airshed' refers to a geographical area in which the movement of air is interconnected. In one of its reports, the World Bank identified six major airsheds across South Asia. One of them is the 'West/Central Indo-Gangetic Plains', which includes several Indian states and Pakistan's Punjab region.
The World Bank has recommended cross-border cooperation because no single city, state or country can significantly reduce pollution levels on its own. This is particularly true when achieving such reductions independently may also involve high costs.
The timing could also provide an opportunity to initiate discussions. Pakistan's Climate Change Minister will be in New Delhi from November 20 to 22 to participate in the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) Civilisational Dialogue. The visit could be used to begin discussions on the strained environmental relationship between the two countries and the need for technical cooperation to tackle smog.
A recent editorial in Dawn has also recommended such engagement. On several previous occasions, multilateral meetings have opened channels of communication between India and Pakistan. At these gatherings, the two countries have sometimes reached agreements and, on other occasions, merely agreed to continue discussions.
The first step should be a joint study examining how pollution generated in one country affects the other, particularly during winter. Both countries could share effective practices for reducing stubble burning and limiting its harmful consequences. They could also encourage farmers on both sides to adopt alternative agricultural practices.
Other possible areas of cooperation include sharing satellite data on fire incidents in agricultural fields, issuing timely public health advisories and providing weather forecasts. Such discussions should not be limited to political leaders. Scientists and policy experts should also be involved to help advance dialogue on environmental policies.
Cooperation between India and Pakistan on this specific issue would not necessarily lead to an improvement in their overall bilateral relations. However, if both countries can set aside their differences and work together to protect public health by tackling air pollution, it could establish an example for engagement on other issues as well.
It remains an unusual reality that people in India and Pakistan are forced to breathe the same toxic air despite the political boundaries separating them. As Maryam Nawaz remarked in 2024, "Winds do not know that there is a line [border] between them."

Comment List