Balen Shah's India Visit: Can Nepal's New PM Reset Ties With Delhi?
Nepal PM Balen Shah's India visit raises hopes of a diplomatic reset with Delhi. From border disputes and hydropower to air routes and a $5 billion reconstruction challenge, several crucial issues are on the agenda.
The visit is particularly significant as it is Shah's first bilateral foreign trip since his party, the Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP), came to power in March. The party secured power six months after the government of KP Sharma Oli collapsed following the Gen Z movement against corruption and nepotism.
The 36-year-old former rapper-turned-politician is arriving in Delhi on Sunday for a two-day visit. During his stay, he will meet Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and other senior officials. Discussions are expected to cover several key issues, including economic and energy cooperation, the opening of additional air corridors and a reconstruction assistance package following the devastating flash floods that struck Nepal in August.
The disaster claimed more than 1,450 lives in the Himalayan country, while hundreds of people remain missing and their whereabouts are still unknown.
India and Nepal share deep ethnic, cultural, religious and economic ties. The two countries are connected by an approximately open border stretching more than 1,750 kilometres. Situated between India and China, Nepal holds strategic importance as a buffer state. Analysts say Nepal's stability has a direct bearing on India's security.
However, relations between the two neighbours have also experienced tensions over the decades due to border disputes, allegations of political interference and resentment in Nepal over what many consider India's 'big brother' attitude.
Despite these differences, analysts believe Shah's visit could provide an opportunity to reset bilateral relations.
Former Indian ambassador Ranjit Rae told the BBC, "Nepal's new leadership says it does not carry the political baggage of the past. It wants to focus on development, diplomacy and economic partnerships."
He added, "They appear more pragmatic and less ideological. Personally, I think this is an optimistic moment."
Nepal abolished its monarchy and became a democratic republic in 2008. Since then, three political parties have dominated the country's politics and governance.
New Delhi has maintained close contacts with all three parties: the Communist Party of Nepal (CPN-UML), the Nepali Congress and the Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist Centre).
Nepal's communist parties have traditionally been considered closer to India’s rival, China, because of their ideological links. These parties have also frequently criticised bilateral agreements with New Delhi, arguing that they are unequal.
Given Nepal's strategic location, both Delhi and Beijing have sought to expand their influence in Kathmandu. This has frequently led to accusations that the two Asian powers are interfering in Nepal's internal affairs.
However, relations between Nepal and India extend beyond diplomacy and strategic interests. The two Hindu-majority countries share deep social connections. Families live on both sides of their open border, while communities maintain regular interactions across it.
Bilateral trade between the two countries exceeds $9 billion. However, a substantial portion of this trade favours India, a longstanding source of dissatisfaction in Kathmandu.
India is a major supplier of petroleum products and several food commodities to Nepal. It also serves as an important transit route for Nepal's trade with other countries.
Hydropower is another significant area of cooperation. India has approved projects to import up to 1,200 megawatts of electricity from Nepal and plans to increase these imports in the future.
Ranjit Rae said, "India has a huge demand for electricity, and Nepal has enormous potential to generate power because of its water resources and geographical position. This is not limited to bilateral cooperation. Nepal also exports electricity to Bangladesh through India."
India has frequently been among the first countries to provide assistance during major natural disasters in Nepal, including the 2015 earthquake and the devastating flash floods in August this year.
Despite their close relationship, India and Nepal have also faced significant disagreements.
In 2019, Nepal expressed strong resentment after India published a map showing certain western territories near the Chinese border as part of Indian territory. Kathmandu also claims these areas. The incident further heightened awareness of the disputed territory in Nepal.
The diplomatic dispute escalated after Nepal published its own separate map, which also included the contested territories.
Senior Nepali political analyst Kanak Mani Dixit told the BBC, "I hope that this time Nepal's prime minister will raise the border dispute issue with Delhi. A solution may not emerge immediately, but discussions should begin to resolve the problem."
Nepal has also been seeking additional air entry routes from India for a long time. These routes would allow larger aircraft to approach the newly built airports in Bhairahawa and Pokhara from the western direction.
Bhairahawa is located near Lumbini, a sacred site for Buddhists, while Pokhara is one of Nepal's major tourism centres.
Access to Indian airspace would reduce flight times and operating costs. It could also make the airports commercially viable by enabling more flights.
Some people in Nepal believe Delhi remains cautious because the Gautam Buddha International Airport was constructed by China's Northwest Civil Aviation Airport Company. Pokhara Airport, meanwhile, was also built with Chinese financial assistance.
Shah has so far avoided making any overt diplomatic overtures towards Beijing. However, ahead of his India visit, he sent a 20-member delegation of parliamentarians from his party to China on an 11-day trip beginning November 15.
The move is being viewed as an attempt to maintain balanced relations with Nepal's two powerful neighbours, India and China.
Shah had promised not to undertake any foreign visits during his first year in office. However, the devastating flash floods in August changed the circumstances.
His government estimates that reconstruction will cost approximately $5 billion, while the international assistance announced so far has fallen short of expectations.
Nevertheless, some observers in Nepal believe Shah's preparations for this important visit to India have not been entirely adequate.
Kanak Mani Dixit said, "Prime Minister Shah and his advisers are young and new, but they lack experience. They have often demonstrated a lack of seriousness in governance, whereas this is extremely important when conducting diplomacy with such a powerful neighbour."
Shah has also faced criticism over some recent government decisions, including the removal of police chief Dan Bahadur from his position.
He is accused of having refused to follow the directions of the Prime Minister's Office.
Police were also sent to detain journalists at some news organisations over their reporting. The action triggered allegations that the government was attempting to restrict press freedom.
Kathmandu is keen to take its relationship with India to the next level. However, the real test for Shah will be whether he can return from the visit with concrete achievements.
If he secures a clear and tangible commitment from Delhi on financial assistance, it would be considered a diplomatic success and could also help ease some of the growing criticism he faces at home.

Comment List