Mohammed Kaif Slams Team Management Over Siraj and Jadeja's Exclusion
Mohammed Kaif has questioned India's decision to drop Mohammed Siraj and Ravindra Jadeja against New Zealand in Wellington. His criticism of the team management highlights concerns over player selection and recent performances.
Speaking on his YouTube channel, the former Indian batter strongly questioned the management's decisions. Kaif believes overlooking an experienced fast bowler like Siraj in overseas conditions is difficult to understand, particularly after his crucial contribution to India's success during the England tour.
Kaif highlighted Siraj's performance in the five-match Test series against England, where the fast bowler emerged as India's leading wicket-taker with 23 wickets. His performances played a significant role in helping India level the series 2-2.
Siraj was particularly impressive in the final Test at The Oval, where India registered a thrilling six-run victory. He claimed five wickets in the second innings and finished the match with nine wickets, playing a decisive role in India's memorable win.
Questioning the logic behind Siraj's exclusion, Kaif asked why a bowler who had delivered match-winning performances in challenging English conditions was not included in the playing XI in New Zealand. He also questioned whether the team management had completely overlooked Siraj's achievements in overseas conditions.
Kaif also dismissed the argument that Siraj's performance during the Sri Lanka tour justified his exclusion. According to him, conditions in Sri Lanka and across the Indian subcontinent have traditionally been challenging for fast bowlers, as most pitches are prepared to assist spin bowling. Consequently, spinners naturally tend to collect more wickets.
He explained that fast bowlers have a limited role on spin-friendly pitches. Their responsibilities often include bowling with the new ball during the opening spells and delivering a few overs in between to provide rest to the spinners. Under such circumstances, expecting fast bowlers to take wickets consistently is not reasonable.
Kaif maintained that failing to pick up wickets in Sri Lanka does not mean Siraj has lost his bowling ability. He argued that an experienced fast bowler should be assessed on the basis of his overall performances, particularly his record in overseas conditions.
Taking a swipe at the team management's selection approach, Kaif also brought up the example of legendary batter Sachin Tendulkar. He remarked that if the current team management had its way, even a player like Tendulkar could be dropped after two or three poor matches or one disappointing series.
Kaif suggested that the management had previously taken similar decisions involving several players and that Siraj appeared to be facing the same treatment. He stressed that every international cricketer experiences ups and downs during a career, but one poor series cannot erase years of contribution and match-winning performances.
Apart from Siraj, Kaif also questioned the decision to exclude Ravindra Jadeja from the playing XI. He pointed out that Jadeja has taken more than 350 wickets in Test cricket and has been among India's most dependable all-rounders for a long time. Despite this, Kaif felt that giving preference to Washington Sundar over Jadeja was not the right decision.
Jadeja had also delivered an impressive batting performance during India's England tour. In the second Test at Edgbaston, Birmingham, in July 2025, he scored 89 runs in the first innings and remained unbeaten on 69 in the second innings. India won that match by 336 runs.
Moreover, Jadeja scored 516 runs in the five-match Test series against England, maintaining an outstanding batting average of 86. His tally included one century and five half-centuries.
Kaif believes that a player with such an impressive record and experience should not be overlooked. While acknowledging Washington Sundar's talent as an all-rounder, he emphasised that Jadeja's experience and recent performances should also have been given due consideration during selection.
Kaif further argued that the exclusion of experienced players was not an isolated incident. According to him, several cricketers had faced similar treatment in the past, and the same approach now appeared to be affecting both Siraj and Jadeja.
He maintained that providing opportunities to young players is important, but it should not come at the cost of ignoring the previous performances of experienced cricketers who have delivered match-winning contributions for India.
The biggest question surrounding Siraj's exclusion remains why India's leading wicket-taker in the England Test series, who delivered under challenging overseas conditions, was not considered the first choice in New Zealand, where conditions were expected to favour fast bowlers.
The selection decision has reportedly left not only Kaif but also former cricketers Sunil Gavaskar and Ravi Shastri surprised. However, the team management has defended its selection for the Wellington Test. Batting coach Sitanshu Kotak said the management had fielded its best XI, maintaining that the selected combination was the right choice for the match.

Comment List