CAG Audit Flags Major Lapses in BIS Gold Hallmarking Inspections Across India
A CAG draft audit report has exposed major gaps in BIS gold hallmarking inspections, with only 5,444 of 28,865 licensed jewellers inspected in 2024-25, raising concerns over consumer protection and gold purity.
In Indian society, gold is more than just a precious metal; it represents a legacy of trust. Jewellery owned by a mother often holds her lifetime savings, serves as financial support for farmers during difficult times and provides middle-class families with security for their daughters' futures. Gold purchases are therefore not merely commercial transactions but are closely connected to the financial and emotional lives of millions of households. When questions arise over the government system responsible for ensuring gold purity, the issue goes beyond fraud by individual jewellers. It raises concerns about government accountability and the credibility of consumer protection mechanisms.
The draft audit report prepared by the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has highlighted serious shortcomings in the functioning of the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS). According to the report, only 5,444 out of 28,865 licensed jewellers across the country were inspected in the financial year 2024-25. This means that approximately 81 per cent of establishments did not undergo their prescribed annual inspections.
The report also states that the proportion of jewellers left out of inspections over the past five years stood at 83.25 per cent. The BIS also fell 43.7 per cent short of its prescribed monitoring target for Assaying and Hallmarking Centres, where gold purity is tested.
It is important to note that the absence of an inspection does not necessarily mean that adulterated gold is being sold at a particular jewellery store. However, the lack of regular inspections weakens the possibility of detecting violations and penalising those responsible. The central question is why the institution entrusted with ensuring the purity of gold has failed to establish an effective monitoring mechanism.
Staff shortages and geographical challenges may be cited as reasons for the shortfall, but these are not newly emerging problems. Ensuring adequate resources to monitor such a large market, which involves the savings of millions of people, is a fundamental responsibility of the regulator.
Mandatory hallmarking has now been extended to 398 districts across India. The BIS has also introduced a six-digit alphanumeric Hallmark Unique Identification (HUID) number for jewellery, making identification and verification easier. However, assigning digital identities to millions of jewellery items and effectively monitoring their purity are two different matters. Technology can inspire confidence only when supported by regular inspections and a strong accountability mechanism. Otherwise, even the hallmark symbol risks becoming nothing more than a formal stamp.
The issue also has implications for the country's economy. According to the World Gold Council, India's gold demand stood at 797.3 tonnes in 2021, 774.1 tonnes in 2022, 761 tonnes in 2023 and 802.8 tonnes in 2024. In 2025, demand declined to 710.9 tonnes amid record-high gold prices. Despite the decline in volume, rising prices increased the financial burden on households. This means people are having to spend more money than before even to purchase smaller quantities of gold.
India meets a significant portion of its domestic gold demand through imports. Payments for gold imports have to be made in foreign currency, increasing the import bill and potentially putting pressure on the current account deficit. This can also affect the foreign exchange market and the stability of the rupee. This is why the government has periodically appealed to citizens to reduce unnecessary gold purchases.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi also urged people to exercise restraint in purchasing gold in May 2025. However, this raises a fundamental question: when the government asks citizens to buy less gold, is it ensuring that those who spend their hard-earned money on gold receive the promised purity?
Concerns over saving foreign exchange are valid, but protecting citizens' savings is equally a government responsibility.
It would also be inappropriate to describe gold entirely as an idle or unproductive investment. For Indian families, it serves as a means of raising loans and meeting essential expenses such as medical treatment and children's education during financial emergencies. Jewellery owned by women is often one of their most important sources of financial security. Therefore, the problem is not the tradition of purchasing gold but an economic structure in which a significant portion of domestic savings remains invested in imported precious metal, while other reliable and productive investment options fail to reach ordinary citizens with sufficient appeal.
Regulated investment options such as Gold Exchange-Traded Funds (Gold ETFs) can be useful. However, Digital Gold and Gold ETFs should not be treated as identical products. They differ in their regulatory frameworks and investor protection mechanisms.
Meanwhile, consumer fraud in the jewellery market remains a serious concern. Common complaints include selling gold of lower purity in the name of 22-carat gold, adding the weight of gemstones embedded in jewellery to the gold weight, and imposing arbitrary charges under the names of making charges and wastage.
The fineness, or purity, of 22-carat gold is 916, equivalent to 91.6 per cent. For 18-carat gold, the fineness is 750, or 75 per cent, while 14-carat gold has a fineness of 585, or 58.5 per cent. The remaining portion consists of other metals mixed with gold to provide strength to jewellery. Even within 24-carat gold, separate purity standards exist in the form of 24KS and 24KF. Therefore, relying solely on the carat designation is not sufficient when purchasing gold.
The silver market also raises concerns. Hallmarking of silver in India is voluntary. From September 2025, HUID-based identification was made mandatory for hallmarked silver articles. However, this does not mean that every silver item sold in the market is required to carry a hallmark. In the case of both gold and silver, consumers must receive clear information about the purity and weight of the items they purchase.
The government must now move beyond highlighting registration numbers and digital identification as achievements. The BIS needs to strengthen its inspection mechanism, recruit an adequate number of technical personnel and ensure regular surprise inspections of jewellers and hallmarking centres. Inspection findings should be made public, and the status of establishments that have not been inspected within the prescribed period must be clearly disclosed.
The process of securing compensation for consumers who discover purity deficiencies in hallmarked jewellery must also be made simpler and time-bound.
Consumers, meanwhile, should check the BIS mark, purity marking and HUID before purchasing gold. The authenticity of jewellery can be verified through the Verify HUID facility on the BIS Care app. Bills must separately mention details of the jewellery, the actual weight of gold, its purity, the weight of gemstones and making charges.
However, the government and regulatory institutions cannot escape accountability by placing the entire responsibility on consumers. If citizens are expected to become experts every time they purchase gold to protect themselves from fraud, while the regulator fails to conduct even its prescribed inspections, it reflects a failure of the consumer protection system.
The government must decide whether its concerns are limited to reducing gold imports and conserving foreign exchange or whether protecting the hard-earned savings of ordinary citizens is also a priority. When trust in hallmarking is undermined, the damage is not limited to an individual consumer; it affects the credibility of the entire system.

Comment List